Epic Games CEO, Tim Sweeney, has reignited criticisms against Google, alleging the tech giant is deliberately delaying compliance with the European Union’s Digital Markets Act (DMA). The DMA, a landmark antitrust legislation, prohibits tech companies from hindering developers’ access to digital marketplaces through avenues like alternative app stores.
Epic’s Ongoing Legal Battle
Epic Games has locked horns with both Google and Apple on multiple fronts, including exorbitant fees (taking a 30% cut of game transactions within their marketplaces) and restrictions imposed on developers that prevent them from promoting alternative stores with potentially lower fees. Google has responded to the DMA, but Sweeney accuses both Apple and Google of stalling compliance efforts.
This isn’t the first time these issues have been in the spotlight. In Apple’s antitrust case, Epic lost most rulings, but a federal judge did acknowledge that Apple policies fostered unfair competition. However, Epic won a jury trial in their antitrust case against Google in December 2023. The EU’s DMA serves to codify some of these principles for fairer competition.
The Spotify Precedent
The EU’s hefty $1.9 billion fine against Apple in a similar case involving Spotify and music industry apps serves as a cautionary tale. Sweeney, in a blog post, stated, “Google has announced plans to comply with Europe’s DMA, but the implementation is nowhere to be seen. Furthermore, they’ve replaced one monopolistic policy with a new ‘Google Tax’ levied on web transactions.” Tim Sweeney’s comments echo his previous criticisms of Apple regarding game distribution on the App Store.
Coalition for App Fairness Weighs In
Rick VanMeter, Executive Director of the Coalition for App Fairness (CAF), also levied criticism against Google: “Enforcement of the DMA began less than 48 hours ago, and Google’s response has been a 1000-word blog post obscuring the fact that the Google Play store remains largely non-compliant. This demonstrates that Google isn’t taking their legal obligations seriously. They continue to maintain control over app distribution outside of the Play Store. Further, their new policies force certain developers to pay fees up to 27% for payments that Google processes. This is a harmful move that will stifle the growth and innovation of many developers.”
The Impact on Developers
The debate surrounding the DMA and actions by Google and Apple are crucial for the future of app and games developers. The practices in question can significantly hinder the potential of smaller developers and independent game studios, limiting their reach and profitability. Epic’s push for change and legal battles highlight a struggle between major tech platforms and developers who are seeking fairer terms and a more open digital marketplace.
See more information in the Game News section here.
